IBC 2016: Debenture Trustee and Related Party Status

IBC 2016: Debenture Trustee and Related Party Status

The relationship between a debenture trustee, debenture holder and corporate debtor is an important issue under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC). One significant question is whether a debenture trustee can be treated as a related party of a corporate debtor and, consequently, be excluded from participating in the Committee of Creditors (CoC).

The Supreme Court addressed this issue in ECL Finance Ltd. & Another v. Abhinav Mukherjee & Others (2026), decided on 27 October 2026. The judgment provides important guidance on the interpretation of Section 5(24)(m)(i) and Section 21 of the IBC.

The decision clarifies that participation in the policy-making process does not necessarily require complete control over a company's management. Even a role in navigating important business and policy decisions may be sufficient to establish related-party status.

 
SCC Online®+1

 

1. Introduction to the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016

The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 was enacted to provide a comprehensive legal framework for resolving insolvency and bankruptcy in India. Its primary objective is to ensure time-bound insolvency resolution, maximise the value of assets and balance the interests of creditors and other stakeholders.

Under the IBC, financial creditors play a significant role in the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP). They participate in the Committee of Creditors, which considers and votes on resolution plans.

However, the law places restrictions on related-party financial creditors to prevent conflicts of interest and undue influence over insolvency proceedings.

This makes the determination of related-party status particularly important.

2. Who is a Debenture Trustee?

A debenture trustee is an entity appointed to protect the interests of debenture holders.

When a company issues debentures to raise funds, it may appoint a trustee to act on behalf of investors. The trustee performs various responsibilities, including:

  • Protecting the interests of debenture holders.

  • Monitoring compliance with the debenture trust deed.

  • Ensuring that security arrangements are maintained.

  • Monitoring repayment obligations.

  • Taking appropriate action in case of default.

  • Enforcing security rights in accordance with applicable law and contractual documents.

A debenture trustee generally acts in a representative capacity. Its primary responsibility is to protect the interests of the debenture holders.

However, the extent of its powers under the trust deed becomes important when determining whether it has participated in the policy-making process of the corporate debtor.

3. Meaning of Related Party under Section 5(24) of IBC

Section 5(24) of the IBC defines the expression "related party" in relation to a corporate debtor.

The definition covers several categories of persons and entities having specific relationships with the corporate debtor.

Important categories include:

  1. Directors or partners of the corporate debtor and their relatives.

  2. Key managerial personnel and their relatives.

  3. Certain partnership firms and companies connected with directors or managers.

  4. Persons whose advice, directions or instructions are ordinarily followed by the management.

  5. Holding, subsidiary and associate companies.

  6. Persons exercising specified voting rights or control over the composition of the board.

  7. Persons associated with the corporate debtor through participation in policy-making processes.

For the present discussion, Section 5(24)(m)(i) is particularly significant.

It covers any person associated with the corporate debtor on account of participation in its policy-making processes.

This provision is important because a person may qualify as a related party even without holding shares or occupying a formal position as a director.

 
IndiaCode+1

 

4. Section 21 and Exclusion from the Committee of Creditors

Section 21 of the IBC deals with the constitution of the Committee of Creditors.

Generally, the CoC consists of the financial creditors of the corporate debtor.

However, the first proviso to Section 21(2) provides that a financial creditor or authorised representative covered by the relevant provisions, if it is a related party of the corporate debtor, shall not have the right of representation, participation or voting in a CoC meeting.

Section 21(6A)(a) is also important because it deals with financial debts in the form of securities or deposits where a trustee or agent is appointed to act as the authorised representative of financial creditors.

Therefore, if the debenture holder is disqualified as a related party, the position of the trustee representing that debenture holder also becomes relevant.

The objective is to prevent related-party influence in the decision-making process of insolvency resolution.

5. Important Supreme Court Judgment: ECL Finance Ltd. v. Abhinav Mukherjee (2026)

Supreme Court judgment – 27 October 2026

The Supreme Court delivered an important judgment in ECL Finance Ltd. & Another v. Abhinav Mukherjee & Others, reported as 2026 SCC OnLine SC 2252.

The dispute concerned the exclusion of a debenture holder and a debenture trustee from the Committee of Creditors on the ground that they were related parties under the IBC.

Background of the case

The dispute involved:

  • ECL Finance Limited (ECL), the debenture holder and lender.

  • IDBI Trusteeship Services Limited (ITSL), the debenture trustee.

  • Palm Developers Private Limited, the corporate debtor.

  • Saha Infratech Private Limited, the principal borrower and debenture issuer.

The corporate debtor had provided corporate guarantees and security arrangements in connection with financial facilities obtained by the principal borrower.

ECL held the debentures, while ITSL acted as the debenture trustee.

During the CIRP of Palm Developers, both ECL and ITSL submitted financial creditor claims and were included in the CoC.

A homebuyer challenged their inclusion, arguing that their contractual rights gave them substantial influence over the corporate debtor's business and policy decisions.

The NCLT and subsequently the NCLAT accepted the related-party objection. The matter eventually reached the Supreme Court.

 
cdjlawjournal.com+1

 

6. Supreme Court's Analysis of Related-Party Status

The Supreme Court examined Section 5(24)(m)(i) and distinguished the concept of participation in policy-making from the stricter concept of control under Section 29A of the IBC.

The Court explained that establishing related-party status under Section 5(24)(m)(i) does not require a person to be in complete control of the company.

A role in navigating policy decisions and directing business interests may be sufficient.

The Court examined several contractual documents, including:

  • Debenture Trust Deed.

  • Facility Agreement.

  • Articles of Association.

  • Sanction Letter.

  • Other financing and security documents.

These documents gave ECL extensive rights concerning the company's operations and projects.

The relevant powers included:

  1. Appointment of nominee directors and observers.

  2. Influence over the appointment and removal of managerial personnel.

  3. Supervision of project implementation.

  4. Approval and modification of construction budgets.

  5. Monitoring of business plans.

  6. Control over project revenues and escrow accounts.

  7. Influence over the sale of project units.

The Court observed that these powers went beyond ordinary protective rights of a lender or debenture holder.

They provided a proactive role in steering the company's business activities.

Consequently, ECL was found to be associated with the corporate debtor through participation in its policy-making process under Section 5(24)(m)(i).

 
cdjlawjournal.com+1

 

7. Can a Debenture Trustee Also Be Excluded?

One of the most important aspects of the judgment concerns the position of the debenture trustee.

The Supreme Court considered the relationship between ECL, the debenture holder, and ITSL, the debenture trustee.

The Court noted that ITSL was acting to protect the interests of ECL, which was the sole debenture holder.

Since ECL was disqualified from participating in the CoC because of its related-party status, ITSL could not independently represent ECL's interests in the CoC through the trustee arrangement.

The Court therefore upheld the exclusion of the debenture trustee along with the related-party debenture holder.

This does not mean that every debenture trustee automatically becomes a related party merely because it has been appointed by a company.

The decision must be understood in the context of the contractual arrangements, the powers conferred and the representative capacity in which the trustee acts.

8. Difference Between Negative Control and Participation in Policy-Making

The judgment also highlights an important distinction between negative control and participation in policy-making.

Negative or protective rights

Participation in policy-making

Protecting repayment interests

Influencing business decisions

Monitoring financial compliance

Directing project implementation

Ensuring security maintenance

Influencing management appointments

Preventing unauthorised transactions

Approving important business plans

Protecting collateral

Steering business operations

A lender may have certain protective rights without necessarily becoming a related party.

However, when contractual powers enable it to influence the company's policy decisions and business direction, the position may change.

The Supreme Court clarified that the test under Section 5(24)(m)(i) is less stringent than the control test under Section 29A(c) and (g).

9. Role of Earlier Judgments

The Supreme Court also considered important earlier decisions while interpreting the provisions of the IBC.

A. Anuj Jain v. Axis Bank Ltd. (2020)

This judgment discussed financial debt, corporate guarantees and the distinction between financial creditors and other creditors.

In the ECL Finance case, the Supreme Court clarified that a corporate guarantee may constitute financial debt under Section 5(8), even where the corporate debtor is not the principal borrower.

B. Phoenix ARC Pvt. Ltd. v. Spade Financial Services Ltd. (2021)

This judgment is important for understanding related-party financial creditors and their exclusion from the CoC.

It also recognised that financial creditors can challenge the inclusion of entities that claim financial creditor status but are allegedly related parties.

The Supreme Court relied on this principle while considering the objection raised by the homebuyer.

C. ArcelorMittal India Pvt. Ltd. v. Satish Kumar Gupta (2019)

This judgment examined the concept of control under Section 29A of the IBC.

The ECL Finance judgment distinguished the stricter control requirement under Section 29A from the policy-making participation test under Section 5(24)(m)(i).

 
SCC Online®+1

10. Final Decision of the Supreme Court

The Supreme Court dismissed the appeals and upheld the exclusion of ECL Finance Limited and IDBI Trusteeship Services Limited from the Committee of Creditors.

The Court concluded that:

  • ECL had extensive influence over the corporate debtor's policy implementation and business activities.

  • Its contractual rights established participation in the policy-making process.

  • ECL was therefore a related party under Section 5(24)(m)(i).

  • ITSL, acting to protect the interests of the related-party debenture holder, could not participate in the CoC in that representative capacity.

  • The subsequent assignment of ECL's lending rights was not accepted as a bona fide assignment capable of avoiding the related-party exclusion, considering its timing and surrounding circumstances.

The Court found no valid ground to interfere with the NCLAT's decision.

 
cdjlawjournal.com+1

 

11. Legal Significance of the Judgment

The judgment is significant for financial institutions, debenture trustees, insolvency professionals, corporate borrowers and investors.

It establishes important guidance for examining contractual arrangements in insolvency proceedings.

First, the mere appointment of a debenture trustee does not automatically establish related-party status.

Second, contractual powers must be examined to determine whether they extend beyond ordinary creditor protection.

Third, participation in policy-making does not require complete control over the corporate debtor.

Fourth, a trustee cannot use its representative position to enable a related-party debenture holder to participate indirectly in the CoC.

Finally, the judgment reinforces the objective of maintaining independence and fairness in the insolvency resolution process.