Income Tax Reassessment: Mandatory Notice Under Section 143(2)

Income Tax Reassessment: Mandatory Notice Under Section 143(2)

Income tax reassessment is an important mechanism through which the Income Tax Department can examine income that may have escaped assessment. However, the power to reassess a taxpayer's income is not unlimited. The Assessing Officer (AO) must follow the procedure prescribed under the Income-tax Act, including the applicable requirements relating to statutory notices.

One of the important legal questions in reassessment proceedings is whether a notice under Section 143(2) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 is mandatory when an assessee files a return of income in response to a notice under Section 148.

Section 143(2) provides an important procedural safeguard by allowing the Assessing Officer to scrutinise a return and require supporting evidence from the taxpayer.

Several judicial decisions have emphasised that, where a return is furnished and taken up for scrutiny during reassessment proceedings, the statutory requirement of issuing a notice under Section 143(2) cannot ordinarily be ignored.

This issue is particularly important for taxpayers challenging reassessment orders passed without following the prescribed procedure.

1. What Is Section 143(2) of the Income-tax Act?

Section 143(2) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 deals with the issuance of a scrutiny notice by the Assessing Officer.

After receiving an income tax return, the Assessing Officer may consider it necessary to examine whether:

  • The taxpayer has understated their income.

  • Excessive losses have been claimed.

  • The taxpayer has paid insufficient tax.

  • Certain deductions or exemptions require verification.

  • The information provided in the return requires further examination.

For this purpose, the Assessing Officer issues a notice under Section 143(2), requiring the taxpayer to attend or produce evidence in support of the return.

In ordinary assessment proceedings, the notice must be served within the statutory time limit. Under the existing Section 143(2) framework of the 1961 Act, the general deadline is three months from the end of the financial year in which the return is furnished.

The reassessment context, however, has specific procedural provisions and judicial interpretations that must also be considered.

2. Relationship Between Section 148 and Section 143(2)

Section 148 deals with issuing a notice where the Assessing Officer believes that income has escaped assessment.

Under the reassessment framework of the Income-tax Act, 1961, the general procedure involves:

  1. The Assessing Officer identifies information suggesting that income has escaped assessment.

  2. The applicable procedure under Section 148A is followed, including an opportunity to respond, wherever required.

  3. A notice under Section 148 is issued.

  4. The taxpayer furnishes a return of income in response to the notice.

  5. If the Assessing Officer intends to scrutinise that return and make an assessment under Section 143(3) read with Section 147, the applicable requirement of notice under Section 143(2) must be considered.

The purpose of Section 143(2) is to ensure that the taxpayer receives an opportunity to explain the income declared in the return before an adverse scrutiny assessment is completed.

Therefore, Section 148 and Section 143(2) perform different functions. The former initiates reassessment, while the latter provides the procedural framework for scrutiny of the return.

3. Is Notice Under Section 143(2) Mandatory During Reassessment?

The answer depends on the circumstances and the applicable statutory provisions.

Judicial decisions have recognised that when an assessee files a return in response to a Section 148 notice and the Assessing Officer proceeds to scrutinise that return, the notice under Section 143(2) is generally mandatory.

The requirement cannot simply be ignored because the proceedings originated through reassessment rather than an ordinary income tax return.

However, an important amendment was introduced by the Finance Act, 2023, with effect from 1 April 2023.

Under the amended Section 148, a return furnished beyond the period allowed by the Assessing Officer is not deemed to be a return under Section 139. Consequently, the connected requirement of issuing a Section 143(2) notice does not apply to such a late return.

This distinction is extremely important when examining reassessment proceedings initiated under different legal regimes.

4. Important Judicial Decision: Krishna Kumar Makrania v. DCIT (2025)

An important decision was delivered by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Delhi Bench, in Krishna Kumar Makrania v. DCIT, ITA No. 3214/Del/2024.

The order was pronounced on 5 May 2025.

Facts of the case:

  • The assessee had originally filed an income tax return for Assessment Year 2011–12.

  • Subsequently, the Income Tax Department issued a notice under Section 148.

  • The taxpayer requested the Assessing Officer to treat the original return as the return filed in response to the reassessment notice.

  • The Assessing Officer completed the reassessment under Section 143(3) read with Section 147.

  • However, the statutory notice under Section 143(2) had not been issued.

Decision of the Tribunal:

The ITAT considered the relevant judicial precedents, including the Supreme Court's decision in ACIT v. Hotel Blue Moon (2010), and the Delhi High Court's decision in Shaily Juneja v. ACIT (2024).

The Tribunal held that issuance of notice under Section 143(2) was mandatory in the circumstances of the case. Since the required notice had not been issued, the reassessment proceedings were held to be invalid and were quashed.

The Tribunal also explained that the Finance Act, 2023 amendment concerning late returns was not applicable to the assessment year and circumstances before it.

This decision is significant because it reinforces the importance of following mandatory procedural requirements during reassessment.

 
3214-24-Krishna Kumar Makrania vs DCIT+1

5. What Happens If the Assessing Officer Does Not Issue Section 143(2) Notice?

Failure to issue a mandatory statutory notice can have serious legal consequences.

Depending on the applicable law and facts, the taxpayer may challenge the reassessment on the following grounds:

  • Failure to comply with mandatory statutory procedure.

  • Violation of the prescribed assessment mechanism.

  • Denial of the opportunity to support the return.

  • Lack of legal validity of the resulting scrutiny assessment.

In appropriate cases, the appellate authority or Tribunal may quash the reassessment order.

However, taxpayers should understand that every procedural defect does not automatically invalidate an assessment. The nature of the proceedings, the date of the notice, the filing of the return and subsequent statutory amendments must all be examined.

6. Important Amendment: Finance Act, 2023

The Finance Act, 2023 introduced an important clarification to Section 148.

A return filed beyond the period allowed under Section 148 is not treated as a return under Section 139.

As a result, the consequential requirement of issuing a notice under Section 143(2) does not apply to that particular late return.

This amendment became effective on 1 April 2023.

Therefore, taxpayers must carefully examine whether their reassessment proceedings fall before or after the effective date of this amendment.

A legal argument based on the mandatory issuance of a Section 143(2) notice must be supported by the applicable statutory provisions and relevant judicial decisions.

7. Important Legal Position After 1 April 2026

The Income-tax Act, 2025 came into force on 1 April 2026.

The reassessment provisions under Sections 279–286 of the new Act apply to Tax Years 2026–27 and subsequent tax years.

For earlier tax years, the reassessment provisions of the Income-tax Act, 1961 continue to apply. Pending reassessment proceedings initiated under the old Act also continue under its applicable framework.

Therefore, Section 143(2) remains relevant when analysing reassessment proceedings governed by the 1961 Act. Taxpayers dealing with the new Act must examine its corresponding assessment provisions rather than automatically applying the old section numbers.

 
Income Tax Department+1

8. What Should Taxpayers Do If They Have Not Received a Section 143(2) Notice?

Taxpayers facing reassessment proceedings should take the following precautions:

  1. Download and preserve the original Section 148 notice.

  2. Check the date on which the reassessment return was filed.

  3. Preserve the acknowledgement of the return.

  4. Check whether a Section 143(2) notice was issued and served.

  5. Examine whether the Finance Act, 2023 amendment applies.

  6. Obtain copies of the assessment order and relevant communications.

  7. Consult a qualified tax professional before challenging the reassessment.

A taxpayer should not ignore a notice merely because there may be a procedural defect. The appropriate legal remedy must be selected after examining the complete assessment record.

9. Conclusion

Section 143(2) plays an important role in protecting taxpayers during scrutiny and reassessment proceedings under the Income-tax Act, 1961.

The judicial position, particularly the Delhi ITAT decision in Krishna Kumar Makrania v. DCIT (2025), highlights that where a valid return is furnished and taken up for scrutiny, the Assessing Officer must comply with the applicable statutory requirement of issuing a Section 143(2) notice.

At the same time, the Finance Act, 2023 amendment creates an important exception for returns furnished beyond the permitted period under Section 148.

With the introduction of the Income-tax Act, 2025 from 1 April 2026, taxpayers must also distinguish between proceedings governed by the old Act and those governed by the new legislation.

Understanding these procedural safeguards can help taxpayers protect their legal rights and challenge reassessment orders where the law has not been followed.

Legal disclaimer: This article is intended for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal or tax advice. The outcome of an individual reassessment matter depends on its facts, applicable statutory provisions and judicial precedents.